WordPress vs a custom coded website: which is better for a small business?
WordPress is the better choice if you edit your site often or need a store or a members' area. A coded site is the better choice if you want speed, low upkeep and nothing to update. Neither ranks better by default. What matters is how the site is built and looked after.
Weigh it for your business- Free
- WordPress software. Hosting and plugins cost extra
- $10
- Our hosting for a coded site, a month, or host it yourself
- $0
- A 14-page site for our first 10 clients
The short answer
We build coded sites, so read this knowing which side we are on. We have tried to be fair to WordPress, and we maintain WordPress sites for clients who are better off staying on it.
Weigh it for your business
0WordPress
0Coded site
Answer the questions. Each one adds a point to the side it favours.
How often is the site edited?
Many small business sites are edited twice a year.
Do you need a store, a members' area or booking?
A plugin already does those well.
Is your current site slow?
A heavy theme and a page builder are the usual reason.
How do you feel about plugin updates?
Out-of-date plugins are the usual way in.
Platform fees?
A coded site has hosting and nothing else to renew.
What each one is
WordPress is free software that runs your site from a database. You log in to a dashboard to edit pages. A theme controls the look, and plugins add features such as forms, stores and booking.
A custom coded site is written for your business, page by page, with no dashboard, theme or plugins. Changes are made in the code. Ours are built with Next.js and the code sits in a repository you own.
How they compare
| Item | WordPress | Custom coded site |
|---|---|---|
| Speed | Depends on the theme and plugins. A page builder such as Elementor often slows it down | Fast by default, because only the code the page needs is loaded |
| Editing | You log in and edit, with no developer needed | A developer makes the change, or you learn to edit the files |
| Upkeep | Core, theme and plugins need regular updates | Nothing to update |
| Security | Out-of-date plugins are the usual way in | Very little to attack, because there is no login page or database |
| Features | A plugin exists for almost anything | Anything can be built, but it has to be built |
| Yearly cost | Hosting, plus any paid plugins and builder subscription | Hosting. Ours is $10 a month, or free if you host it yourself |
| Moving away | Easy to find another WordPress developer | You own the code, and any developer who knows the framework can take it on |
Speed
WordPress itself is not slow. What slows it down is usually a heavy theme, a page builder and a long list of plugins, all loading on every page.
Google measures how quickly a page responds when someone taps it. Sites built on page builders often struggle with that score. Why page-builder sites struggle with INP.
A coded site starts with an advantage here, but a badly coded site can be slow too. Test any site before you judge the platform. The free website audit checks yours in about a minute.
Cost over three years
The build fee is only part of it. Add these up for any quote:
- The build.
- Hosting for 36 months.
- Paid plugins, theme licences and page builder subscriptions, renewed each year.
- Maintenance: updates and fixes, either as a plan or by the hour.
- Changes you will want made.
A cheap WordPress build with four paid plugins and a monthly care plan can cost more over three years than a coded site that costs more up front. The reverse can also be true. Ask each company for the three-year total in writing.
Our prices: a 14-page coded site is free for our first 10 clients, then from $625. See every price.
Editing it yourself
This is where WordPress wins. If someone on your team posts news, changes prices weekly or adds products, a dashboard matters.
Be honest about how often that happens. Many small business sites are edited twice a year. If that is you, the dashboard is something you pay to keep secure and never use.
Security
Most WordPress break-ins come through plugins that were not updated. If you run WordPress:
- Update the core, the theme and the plugins regularly.
- Remove plugins you do not use.
- Use a strong password and two-step login for every admin.
- Keep a backup somewhere other than the server.
A coded site has no admin login and no plugins, so most of that list does not apply.
SEO
Google does not prefer one platform. It rewards pages that load quickly, answer the search and are easy to read on a phone. Both can do that.
WordPress has good SEO plugins that handle titles and structured data for you. On a coded site, those are written into each page. The result is the same if the work is done.
Choose WordPress if
- You or your staff edit the site every week.
- You need a store, a members' area or a booking system that a plugin already does well.
- You already have a WordPress site that loads fast and brings in calls.
Choose a coded site if
- Nobody on your team edits the site.
- Your current site is slow and a page builder is the reason.
- You are tired of plugin updates breaking things.
- You want to own the code outright and pay no platform fees.
Already on WordPress?
You have two options. Keep it and have it looked after properly, or move. Migration is $599 for a fixed list of pages, with every old address redirected to its new one. Migration moves the site you have. It is not a redesign and comes with no ranking promises.
Not sure which? Read rebuild or optimise.
Questions
Is WordPress bad for SEO?
No. A fast, well-kept WordPress site can rank as well as any other. A slow one will struggle, as any slow site does.
Can I edit a coded site myself?
Small text changes, yes, if you are comfortable editing a file. Most of our clients send us the change instead.
Will I lose rankings if I move from WordPress?
Keeping the same addresses and redirecting every page is how you protect them. Nobody can honestly promise a position.
Is a coded site more expensive?
Not always. Compare the three-year total, not the build fee.
What about Wix or Squarespace?
They are simpler than WordPress and more limited. See Wix compared with an agency build.
Have your site looked at
A free 30-minute call with the founder. Bring your current site, and we will tell you straight whether to keep it, fix it or move it.
Book a free call