Web design agency vs freelancer: who should build your website?
A good freelancer is usually cheaper and easier to talk to. An agency usually costs more and is less likely to disappear. For a small business site, the person matters more than the label. This page shows how to check either one.
Weigh it for your business- 7
- Questions to ask either one before you hire
- 14
- Days to launch with us, on a fixed price
- $0
- A 14-page site for our first 10 clients
The short answer
We are a small Calgary agency with published fixed prices, so we sit between the two. Read this with that in mind.
Weigh it for your business
0Freelancer
0Agency
Answer the questions. Each one adds a point to the side it favours.
How big is the site?
One person's strengths are often design or code, less often both.
Do you need it by a fixed date?
A freelancer is fast when you are their main project, slow when you are not.
Who will manage the project?
Someone has to chase the content and the decisions.
Who answers for it next year?
After launch depends on whether the freelancer is still freelancing.
How they compare
| Item | Freelancer | Agency |
|---|---|---|
| Price | Usually lower. One person, low overheads | Usually higher. You pay for a team and an office |
| Who you talk to | The person doing the work | Often an account manager |
| Skills | One person's strengths. Often strong in design or code, less often both | Design, code, writing and SEO from different people |
| Speed | Fast when you are their main project. Slow when you are not | Depends on their queue. Ask for a date in writing |
| If they are ill or busy | The project waits | Someone else picks it up |
| After launch | Depends on whether they are still freelancing | A support process, usually paid |
| Contract | Sometimes informal | Usually a written agreement |
These are tendencies. There are careful freelancers and careless agencies.
When a freelancer is the better choice
- Your site is small and simple: a few pages and a contact form.
- You have seen their work and spoken to two of their clients.
- You are comfortable managing the project and chasing the content yourself.
- You have a plan for who looks after the site if they stop freelancing.
When an agency is the better choice
- You need writing, design, code and SEO together.
- You need the site by a fixed date.
- You want one company to answer for it next year.
- You do not want to manage the project.
The risks, and how to remove them
Most bad website stories come from the same four problems. Each has a simple check.
- They vanish. Ask who holds the logins. The domain, the hosting and the analytics should be in accounts under your name from the first day. Then nobody can leave with them.
- The price grows. Ask for a fixed price for a written list of pages, the number of rounds of changes, and the hourly rate for anything beyond that.
- It never launches. Ask for a launch date in writing, and ask what holds it up. The usual answer is content. Find out who writes it.
- You cannot leave. Ask what you keep if you stop working together. If the site is built on their own platform, the answer may be nothing.
Seven questions to ask either one
- Can I see three sites you built for businesses like mine, and speak to one of those clients?
- What is the fixed price, and what is not included?
- Who writes the words?
- What date will it launch?
- Whose name are the domain, hosting and analytics in?
- What does it cost per year after launch?
- If we part ways, what do I keep?
Good freelancers and good agencies answer all seven without hesitating.
What about doing it yourself?
A website builder is the third option, and it is the cheapest in money and the most expensive in time. See DIY compared with hiring in Calgary.
Where we fit
- Fixed prices, published. A 14-page site is free for our first 10 clients, then from $625. See every price.
- A fixed date. Live in 14 days.
- You talk to the founder, not an account manager.
- You own it. The code goes in your own repository. The domain and analytics are in your name.
- We write the first draft of every page.
What we do not include: custom photography, integrations not in your agreement, and ranking promises.
Questions
Is a freelancer always cheaper?
Usually for the build. Compare the cost over three years, including changes and upkeep, before deciding.
How do I check a freelancer's work?
Open their sites on your phone. Check that each loads quickly, that you can call in one tap, and that the business is still using it. Then phone one of the clients.
What should a contract include?
The list of pages, the price, the launch date, the number of rounds of changes, who owns what, and what happens if either side walks away.
Should the same company do my SEO?
It helps if whoever builds the site understands search, because structure and speed are set at build time. The monthly SEO work can be done by someone else. See how to choose a local SEO company.
What if I already hired someone and it went badly?
Start by finding out what you own. Check who holds the domain login. Then run the free website audit to see what state the site is in.
Ask us the seven questions
A free 30-minute call with the founder. Bring the quotes you have, and we will tell you straight which one we would take, even if it is not ours.
Book a free call