Is HomeStars worth it for contractors?

It depends on one number: what a booked job costs you through HomeStars compared with what it costs anywhere else. Most contractors never work that number out. This page shows you how, and what the alternative looks like.

Weigh it for your business
Free
A basic HomeStars listing
⅓
Of your profit per job: the line a lead source must stay under
$0
A 14-page site for our first 10 clients

The short answer

We have not quoted HomeStars prices, because they change and are not published in one place. Ask HomeStars for the current price per lead, and whether each lead goes to more than one contractor.

Weigh it for your business

0HomeStars

0Your own site

Answer the questions. Each one adds a point to the side it favours.

  1. How established are you?

    HomeStars helps most when you have no reviews and no website traffic yet.

  2. How fast do you answer a lead?

    A lead that sits for an hour has usually been booked by someone else.

  3. How big are your jobs?

    On small jobs the lead fee eats the margin.

  4. Have you worked out your cost per job?

    If you have not, you do not know whether it pays.

What HomeStars is

HomeStars is a Canadian directory where homeowners look up and review home service companies. It is owned by Angi, the American company behind HomeAdvisor. A basic listing is free. The paid side sells you leads or placement.

Work out your real cost per job

Do this with three months of your own invoices. It takes ten minutes.

  1. Add up everything you paid HomeStars in those three months.
  2. Count the leads you received.
  3. Count how many of those became paid jobs.
  4. Divide the total by the number of jobs.

That is your cost per job. Now compare it with your average profit on a job, not your revenue.

If the cost per job is under a third of your profit, it is paying for itself. If it is close to your profit, you are working for the directory.

When HomeStars is worth it

  • You are new, and you have no reviews and no website traffic yet.
  • You answer every lead within minutes. Speed decides who wins a lead.
  • Your jobs are large enough that one win covers many lost leads.
  • You track the numbers above and they hold up.

When it is not

  • You are slow to respond. A lead that sits for an hour has usually been booked by someone else.
  • Your jobs are small. The lead fee eats the margin.
  • The reviews you earn live on their site, not yours. If you stop paying, the visibility goes with it.
  • You have never worked out the cost per job.

The alternative: own the places customers find you

A paid lead is rented. When you stop paying, it stops. Three things you own keep working:

  • Your Google Business Profile. For most local jobs, the map results sit above every directory. Reviews you collect there stay with you. Use the Google Business Profile optimization checklist.
  • Your own website. One page for each service and each area you cover, with a phone number that can be tapped and a quote form on the first screen.
  • Your follow-up. A text back on every missed call, and a reminder on every open quote.

The full picture is in lead generation for contractors.

HomeStars compared with your own website

ItemHomeStarsYour own website and Google profile
CostQuoted by HomeStars. Ask for the current price per leadA 14-page site is free for our first 10 clients, then from $625. SEO is optional, from $500 a month
Who else gets the leadAsk HomeStars whether a lead is sent to more than one contractorOnly you
How fast it worksFrom the day you start payingMap results can start to move in 30 to 60 days. Competitive searches take longer
What happens when you stop payingLeads stopThe site, the profile and the reviews stay yours
Where reviews liveOn HomeStarsOn your Google profile

You do not have to choose on day one

Keep HomeStars while your own sources grow. Each month, compare the cost per job from each source. Cut back the one that costs more. For most contractors that takes several months, not weeks.

Questions

Is the free HomeStars listing worth having?

Yes. A free listing with your correct name, address and phone number is one more place that confirms your business exists. Make sure the details match your Google profile exactly.

Are HomeStars reviews as useful as Google reviews?

They help on HomeStars. They do not show in Google's map results. If a customer will only leave one review, ask for it on Google.

How much does HomeStars cost?

We do not publish a figure, because the prices change and are not listed in one place. Ask HomeStars for the price per lead and whether leads are shared, then run the cost-per-job sum above.

Can I do both?

Yes, and most contractors should at first. Track each source separately so you know which one to grow.

How do I know where my calls come from?

Ask every caller, and write it down. Better, use a tracking number on each source. We set up call tracking on every site we build.

See what your own site is missing

Run the free website audit. It takes about a minute and needs no sign-up. Or book a free 30-minute call and we will go through your numbers with you.

Book a free call

Free 30-minute call

Book your free site review

Choose your field

What kind of business do you run?

Pick yours to see how we build the site and the search work for it.